|
|
FILM REVIEWS
Enduring Love (2004)
|
Directed by: Roger Michell
Written by: Ian McEwan, Joe Penhall
Produced by: François Ivernel, Kevin Loader, Cameron McCracken, Ian McEwan, Duncan Reid, Rosa Romero, Tessa Ross
Distributor: Paramount Classics
Starring: Daniel Craig, Rhys Ifans, Samantha Morton, Bill Nighy, Susan Lynch
|
Review by David Haviland
In a remarkable opening scene, Joe (Daniel Craig) and Claire (Samantha Morton) enjoy a romantic picnic in a field. Joe is about to propose, when a hot air balloon suddenly descends, drifting clumsily to earth. The balloon is out of control, with a boy trapped in the basket, so Joe and three other men rush over to help.
 | Rhys Ifans tries hard to invest some humanity into a thanklessly absurd role
|
They each grab a rope, and after much effort they seem to have the balloon grounded, until suddenly a gust of wind seizes it, and three of them let go. As the balloon soars away, we see the last man hanging on, and then falling to his death.
Joe is deeply troubled by this incident, as he suspects he might have been the first person to let go. The accident brings another problem: Jed (Rhys Ifans), who also let go of the rope, and who now feels that he and Joe have some kind of special connection.
It's at this point that the film loses its way, and unfortunately we're still in the first half hour. Jed thinks the experience means he and Joe have fallen in love, and begins following him everywhere. Joe starts going insane under this pressure, and struggles to maintain his relationships and career.
The film is an adaptation of an Ian McEwan novel, in which perhaps the plot and characters are more successfully explained. On film, however, the story quickly becomes ludicrous. Joe seems tormented by Jed, yet never makes any meaningful effort to get rid of him. Instead, he drives away his own friends and girlfriend, for no apparent reason beyond a general sense that he's highly stressed.
The problem is that the film is much more interested in vague themes than in its characters, so the screenplay is littered with pretentious speeches about the nature of love and evolution. None of these moments seem to come naturally from the characters, and the script's treatment of these themes is simplistic and wilfully gloomy.
Daniel Craig and Rhys Ifans try hard to invest some humanity into thanklessly absurd roles; Bill Nighy and Samantha Morton fare better with the more plausible secondary characters. Notting Hill director Roger Michell shoots the film with some style, but he never manages to conceal the falseness of the script. In hindsight, the opening scene seems particularly apt, as the film itself is little more than hot air.
Rating: 2 out of 5 stars
Visit the David Haviland archive on SellAScript.com by clicking here.
|
|
|
|
Script Marketplace
